Riya gets ₹200 pocket money at the start of the month and spends all of it in the first week on…
Riya gets ₹200 pocket money at the start of the month and spends all of it in the first week on stickers and snacks. In the third week, she wants a ₹150 pencil box, but she has no money left. She says she should still be able to buy it because "it's still the same pocket money month." Her friend Zoya disagrees. Who is right?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Zoya is right, money already spent doesn't come back just because the month continues
Why
Riya is treating the month itself as the source of money, as if having pocket-money-month status refills her balance automatically. But the ₹200 was a single, fixed amount for the whole month, not a repeating supply — once she spent all of it in week one, there was nothing left for week one, two, three, or four, because the calendar doesn't hand her new money on its own. What actually determines whether she can afford the ₹150 pencil box in week three is how much of her ₹200 is still unspent, not which week of the month it happens to be. Test: if Riya adds up everything she spent in week one, she'll find it comes to ₹200 — there is nothing left to subtract the pencil box from. Zoya is right: money that's already been spent is gone regardless of how much of the month remains.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →