Rehan downloads a simple offline puzzle game that asks for permission to access his contacts…
Rehan downloads a simple offline puzzle game that asks for permission to access his contacts, camera, and location. He grants everything without thinking, "it's just a small game, what harm could it do." His friend Mehar says these permissions don't match what the game actually needs. Who is right?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Mehar is right, unnecessary permissions can be used to collect data the game doesn't need
Why
Rehan is judging the risk by how simple the game looks, assuming a small, harmless-seeming app can only ever do small, harmless things. But what a game is allowed to do isn't limited by how it looks — it's limited by which permissions it's actually granted, and an offline puzzle game has no real reason to need contacts, camera, or location at all to let someone slide tiles around. Once granted, those permissions let the app read Rehan's contact list, access the camera, and track his location in the background, none of which has anything to do with solving a puzzle — and that data can be collected, stored, or sold without him ever noticing anything different while playing. The mismatch between what a game needs and what it asks for is exactly the signal worth paying attention to, more than the game's size or simplicity. Test: before granting a permission, ask whether the app's actual function requires it — a puzzle game needs no camera, a flashlight app needs no contacts list — a real need justifies a permission, and a missing need is a reason to say no. Mehar is right: permissions that don't match what an app actually does can be used to collect data it has no real reason to need.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in Scams, Fraud and Digital Safety