Two jugs of lemonade. The first has 2 spoons sugar in 4 glasses water; the second has 3 spoons…
Two jugs of lemonade. The first has 2 spoons sugar in 4 glasses water; the second has 3 spoons sugar in 6 glasses water. Neha says the second is sweeter because it has more sugar. Is she right?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: No — both are equally sweet
Why
Neha spotted a true fact — the second jug does have more sugar. But sweetness isn't about total sugar; it's about how much sugar shares each glass of water. More sugar spread through more water can taste exactly the same. Check the pairing: jug one is 2 spoons for 4 glasses, so 1 spoon per 2 glasses. Jug two is 3 spoons for 6 glasses — again 1 spoon per 2 glasses. Same ratio, so same sweetness; the second is just a bigger batch of the identical drink. Test: one biscuit shared by two children, versus three biscuits shared by six — no child eats more in the second; there's just more of everything. Both are equally sweet: taste depends on the sugar-to-water ratio, not the raw amount of sugar — and here the ratio matches.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in Proportional Reasoning