Vikram chats with someone he only knows from an online game
Vikram chats with someone he only knows from an online game. The person asks which school Vikram goes to and what time he walks home. Vikram tells them, thinking it's no big deal since "everyone at school already knows this anyway." His friend Ira disagrees. Who is right?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Ira is right, a classmate knowing something and a stranger knowing it are very different
Why
Vikram is reasoning that since the information isn't secret AT school, sharing it can't matter — but he's ignoring who he's actually telling it to. His classmates already knowing his school and his walk-home time doesn't put him at any risk, because they're people he sees every day in a supervised place; a stranger from an online game knowing exactly which school to find him at and exactly when he'll be walking home alone is a completely different situation, because now someone he knows nothing about has the specific information needed to find him in person. The same fact can be harmless in one context and risky in another, depending entirely on who has it and what they could do with it. Test: ask what a classmate could newly do with that information that they couldn't already do — nothing changes; then ask the same about a stranger — now they know where and when to find him. Ira is right: information being known at school doesn't make it safe to hand to a stranger online.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →