Naina gets a message from an account she doesn't know, saying…
Naina gets a message from an account she doesn't know, saying "I'm Simran's cousin from your class." It asks to be friends online. Naina thinks saying that is proof enough they're safe. Her brother Rehan disagrees. Who is right?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Rehan is right, anyone can claim this whether or not it's true
Why
Naina is treating the claim itself as proof, the way a password works — say the right words and you're let in. But claiming a connection to someone Naina actually knows costs the stranger nothing and needs no proof at all: anyone online can type "I'm Simran's cousin" whether or not it's true, and there's no way for Naina to check it just from the message itself. A real cousin of a real classmate is easy to fake in a chat; it's much harder to fake in person, which is exactly why online claims like this need a different kind of check — like asking Simran directly, separately, whether she has a cousin who'd be messaging Naina. Test: notice that nothing stops anyone from claiming to be connected to anyone else online — the claim alone carries no cost and proves nothing. Rehan is right: a stranger claiming to know someone isn't proof they actually do.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →