Zainab says rivers flow downhill, whichever direction that happens to be — the Nile, for example…
Zainab says rivers flow downhill, whichever direction that happens to be — the Nile, for example, flows north into the Mediterranean Sea. Oliver says rivers always flow south, because south is "down" on the map and water runs down. Who is right?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Zainab is right, rivers flow from higher land to lower land
Why
Oliver is correct that water runs down — that part is exactly right. His mistake is about what 'down' means. On a map hanging on a wall, south is at the bottom, so it looks like 'down'. But that is only how the paper is printed. For water, 'down' means toward the centre of the Earth: from higher ground to lower ground. A river starts in hills or mountains and follows the slope of the land to the sea, in whatever compass direction the land happens to slope. The Nile rises in the highlands of East Africa and flows about 6,650 km north to the Mediterranean. The Rhine in Europe, the Ob and the Lena in Siberia and the Mackenzie in Canada all flow north as well. Test: lay a map flat on the floor instead of hanging it up — south is no longer 'down' at all, and a marble on it rolls wherever the floor tilts. Zainab is right: rivers flow downhill from high land to low land, in any direction.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in World Geography