Hana says summer happens because the Earth is closest to the Sun then, and winter when it is…
Hana says summer happens because the Earth is closest to the Sun then, and winter when it is farthest away. Pablo says that cannot be the reason: when it is summer in the northern half of the world, it is winter in the southern half at exactly the same moment — and both are on the same Earth, at the same distance from the Sun. Whose reasoning holds up?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Pablo is right, the seasons come from the Earth's tilt, not its distance
Why
Hana's idea is the one most people reach for first, because it matches daily life: step closer to a fire and you feel warmer. But Pablo's observation breaks it. Australia has its summer in December while Europe has its winter, and the whole Earth is the same distance from the Sun at that moment — so distance cannot be what separates them. In fact the Earth is closest to the Sun in early January, in the middle of the northern winter. The real cause is that the Earth's axis is tilted by about 23.5 degrees. For half the year the northern half leans toward the Sun: sunlight falls more directly there and the days are longer, so it warms up. Six months later the southern half leans toward the Sun and the pattern swaps. Test: shine a torch straight down on a table, then at a slant — the same light spreads over a bigger, dimmer patch when it arrives at an angle. Pablo is right: the seasons are caused by the tilt of the Earth's axis, which is why the two hemispheres have opposite seasons.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in World Geography