Jana says the claim that "Einstein failed maths at school" is a myth: he was excellent at maths…
Jana says the claim that "Einstein failed maths at school" is a myth: he was excellent at maths and had mastered calculus before he was 15. Leo says it is true — he has read it on several posters, and it is an encouraging thing to believe. Who should be believed?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Jana is right, Einstein was strong at maths from the start
Why
Leo likes the story, and it is easy to see why: if even Einstein failed maths, anyone can recover from a bad mark. A story being comforting, though, is a reason to check it more carefully, not less. Einstein's school records survive, and they show top marks in mathematics. When the claim was shown to him in 1935 he denied it himself, saying he had never failed in mathematics and had mastered differential and integral calculus before he was fifteen. Two real facts probably fed the myth. At sixteen he sat the entrance exam for a university in Zurich two years early and did not get in — but he scored very well in maths and physics; it was the other subjects that let him down. And his Swiss school reversed its marking scale, so that a 6, once the worst mark, became the best. Test: for a claim about a real person, look for their own records or their own words. Jana is right: Einstein never failed maths, and the encouraging lesson does not need a false story to be true.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in World History