Killa says the Inca empire of South America — which stretched for thousands of kilometres — was…
Killa says the Inca empire of South America — which stretched for thousands of kilometres — was run without writing as we know it; they kept their records on knotted, coloured cords called quipu. Henry says running an empire that big without a written script is impossible; they must have had books that were lost. Which of them does the evidence favour?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Killa is right, the Inca kept records with knotted cords
Why
Henry is reasoning from what he knows: every large state he has heard of used writing, so he assumes it is a requirement. But 'I can't imagine it otherwise' is not evidence, and 'they must have had books that were lost' is a claim with nothing behind it. What survives is the quipu: hundreds of them sit in museums. Each is a main cord with many hanging strings; the type of knot and its position on the string record numbers in a base-ten system, and colours mark what is being counted. With them, trained record-keepers tracked people, llamas, stored food and taxes across an empire about 4,000 km long, and runners carried the cords along a network of roads. Spanish writers of the 1500s described the system in use, and no Inca book or inscription has ever been found. Test: when you catch yourself saying 'it must have been so', ask what actual object or record shows it. Killa is right: the Inca ran their empire with quipu, knotted cords, rather than a written script.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in World History