Omar says the pyramids of Giza in Egypt were built by slaves, the way films show it
Omar says the pyramids of Giza in Egypt were built by slaves, the way films show it. Layla says archaeologists have found the workers' own town beside the pyramids — where they were given bread and meat — and their tombs, built with honour close to the king's pyramid. She says they were organised labourers, not slaves. Whose view does the evidence support?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Layla is right, the evidence points to organised labourers
Why
Omar's picture comes from films and old stories, and for a long time almost everyone believed it. But a film is not evidence. In 1990 archaeologists digging beside the Giza pyramids found the town where the builders lived: bakeries, breweries, and huge quantities of cattle, sheep and fish bones — enough meat to feed thousands of workers well. They also found the workers' tombs, built right next to the pyramids of the kings they worked for, with bread and jars for the afterlife. Slaves would not have been given an honoured burial beside a king. Skeletons show hard labour, and also healed fractures, which means injured workers were treated. Test: when a claim comes from a film, ask what was actually dug out of the ground. Layla is right: the evidence shows the pyramids were built by fed, housed and respected Egyptian labourers, not by slaves.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in World History