Ingrid says Viking warriors wore helmets with horns in battle — every picture and every cartoon…
Ingrid says Viking warriors wore helmets with horns in battle — every picture and every cartoon shows them that way. Emeka says not a single horned helmet from the Viking age has ever been dug up. Whose claim deserves more trust?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Emeka is right, there is no archaeological evidence of horned helmets
Why
Ingrid is counting pictures, and there really are thousands of them. But a thousand pictures copied from one another are still only one idea, repeated. What counts is what was found in the ground. Archaeologists have excavated Viking graves, ships and battle sites for more than a century, and the helmets that survive — the best known is from Gjermundbu in Norway — are plain, rounded iron caps with no horns. Horns would also have been a nuisance in a fight: easy to grab, and easy to knock off. So where did the horns come from? Mostly from the 1800s, a thousand years after the Vikings, when painters and the costume designer of a famous opera in 1876 gave their Norse heroes horned and winged helmets, and the image stuck. Test: when everyone 'knows' something about the past, ask who first drew it, and when. Emeka is right: no horned Viking helmet has ever been found, and the famous image was invented centuries later.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in World History