Tariq says writing was invented more than once — in Mesopotamia, for example, and quite separately…
Tariq says writing was invented more than once — in Mesopotamia, for example, and quite separately in Central America, whose people had no contact with the rest of the world. Elena says an idea that big cannot occur twice; writing must have been invented in one place and spread from there to everyone. Whose reasoning fits the evidence?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Tariq is right, writing was invented independently in different places
Why
Elena's instinct is reasonable: ideas do spread, and the alphabet you are reading now really did travel from people to people across thousands of years. But 'it could have spread' is not the same as 'it did'. The oldest known writing comes from Mesopotamia, about 5,300 years ago, where marks pressed into clay began as records of grain and sheep. Thousands of years later, people in Central America — the Olmec, the Zapotec and then the Maya — also developed writing. There was an ocean between the two regions and no contact at all, and the scripts look nothing alike and work differently. The only explanation that fits is that the idea was thought of twice. Most scholars count China as another independent invention. Test: if writing had spread from one place, the scripts should share signs or a trail of in-between versions; between Mesopotamia and Central America there is none. Tariq is right: writing was invented independently more than once, because people facing the same need can reach the same idea.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in World History