Bongani says the size of a country tells you very little about how many people live in it: Canada…
Bongani says the size of a country tells you very little about how many people live in it: Canada is about three times the area of India, yet it has about 40 million people, while India has more than 1.4 billion. Marta says a bigger country naturally has more people — more room, more people. Who is right?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Bongani is right, area does not decide population
Why
Marta's rule sounds like common sense, and for two fields or two rooms it would work. Countries are different, because people do not spread evenly over land; they gather where they can grow food, find water and earn a living. Canada covers nearly 10 million square kilometres, about three times the area of India, but most of it is frozen forest and tundra where farming is impossible, and nearly all Canadians live in a narrow strip along the southern border. India has a third of the area but warm weather, wide river plains and soil that can give two or three harvests a year, and it supports about thirty-five times as many people. Other pairs show the same thing: Australia is huge and has about 27 million people; Bangladesh is small and has more than 170 million. Test: instead of area, look up population density — people per square kilometre — and compare a few countries. Bongani is right: a country's area does not decide its population; climate, water and farmland matter far more.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in World Geography