Luis says it ought to be warmer on top of a mountain, because the top is closer to the Sun
Luis says it ought to be warmer on top of a mountain, because the top is closer to the Sun. Tashi, who lives in the mountains, says it gets colder as you climb; the Sun is so far away that being a few kilometres closer makes no difference. Whose explanation is correct?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Tashi is right, the thin air higher up holds less heat
Why
Luis is using a rule that works at home: move closer to a heater and you feel warmer. The numbers show why it fails here. The Sun is about 150 million km away. The top of the highest mountain on Earth is less than 9 km above the sea. Climbing it brings you closer to the Sun by about six parts in a hundred million — nothing you could ever feel. What does change as you climb is the air. Sunlight passes through air without warming it much; it warms the ground, and the ground then warms the air above it. Air is also a blanket: near sea level it is dense and holds heat well, while high up it is thin and holds very little. So the temperature falls by about 6.5 degrees Celsius for every 1,000 metres you climb, which is why high peaks keep their snow even near the equator. Test: compare the weather forecast for a hill town with the forecast for a city on the plains nearby on the same day. Tashi is right: mountains are colder because the air is thinner higher up, and being a little closer to the Sun makes no difference.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in World Geography