Noa explains that people float in the Dead Sea without even trying, and that the reason is its…
Noa explains that people float in the Dead Sea without even trying, and that the reason is its water is extremely salty — about ten times saltier than the ocean. Finn says the reason is not the salt but the depth: the deeper the water, the harder it pushes you up. Whose explanation is correct?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Noa is right, very salty water is denser
Why
Finn's idea sounds reasonable, because deep water does feel different from a shallow pool. But how well you float does not depend on how much water is underneath you. A person floats just as well in the deep end of a swimming pool as in the middle of the ocean. What matters is how heavy the water is for its volume — its density — compared with your body. The Dead Sea is a lake in the Middle East with no river flowing out of it; water leaves only by evaporating, and the salt stays behind. Over thousands of years that has made it about 34 per cent salt, close to ten times saltier than the ocean. All that dissolved salt makes each litre of its water much heavier than a litre of fresh water, so the water pushes up on a body far more strongly, and people bob on the surface like corks. Test: put a fresh egg in a glass of plain water and it sinks; stir in several spoons of salt and the same egg floats, in the same glass, at the same depth. Noa is right: people float in the Dead Sea because very salty water is denser, not because the water is deep.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in World Geography