Hugo says that because the Earth spins, water going down a sink always swirls one way in the…
Hugo says that because the Earth spins, water going down a sink always swirls one way in the northern half of the world and always the opposite way in the southern half. Wanjiru says the effect is far too weak to matter for something as small as a sink; which way the water turns depends on the shape of the basin and how the water was already moving. Who has it right?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Wanjiru is right, the effect is far too weak for a sink
Why
Hugo has got hold of a real effect and stretched it too far. The Earth's rotation does bend the path of things that move over long distances for a long time. It is called the Coriolis effect, and it is why huge storms spin anticlockwise north of the equator and clockwise south of it. But the effect depends on size and time. A cyclone is hundreds of kilometres across and lasts for days. A sink is half a metre across and empties in seconds; over that distance the Earth's rotation is thousands of times weaker than the tiny leftover currents from filling the basin, the tilt of the plughole or the way you pulled the plug. Those decide the direction. Careful laboratory experiments have detected the effect in a tank, but only with perfectly still water left to settle for a day and drained very slowly. Test: fill the same sink several times and stir it gently one way, then the other, before pulling the plug — you can make it swirl either way, in either hemisphere. Wanjiru is right: the Earth's spin shapes cyclones, but it is far too weak to decide which way a sink drains.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in World Geography