Aziz says putting north at the top of maps is only a custom: in the past many maps were drawn with…
Aziz says putting north at the top of maps is only a custom: in the past many maps were drawn with south or east at the top, and they were just as correct. Greta says north really is "up" — just look at a globe — so a map with south at the top would be upside down and wrong. Who is right?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Aziz is right, north at the top is only a convention
Why
Greta is pointing at the globe on the classroom shelf, where north is indeed on top — but that globe was built by people who had already agreed to put it that way. In space there is no up or down. 'Up' only means away from the centre of the Earth, so it points in a different direction for every person standing on the planet. A map is a drawing, and whoever draws it chooses which edge goes at the top. In 1154 the geographer al-Idrisi made one of the finest world maps of the Middle Ages with south at the top. Many medieval European maps put east at the top, toward the sunrise — the word 'orient', meaning east, is where we get 'to orient a map'. North-up became the habit a few centuries ago, when compasses and sea charts spread. A south-up map shows every coast, distance and direction exactly as correctly; it only looks strange because we are used to the other way. Test: turn a world map upside down and check — every country is still the same shape, in the same place, beside the same neighbours. Aziz is right: north at the top is a convention, not a fact about the Earth.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in World Geography