Freya says that when ice already floating on the sea melts, it hardly raises the sea level at all…
Freya says that when ice already floating on the sea melts, it hardly raises the sea level at all, but when ice resting on land — like the ice sheets of Greenland and Antarctica — melts and runs into the sea, the level does rise. Ibrahim says ice is ice; whichever kind melts, it raises the sea by the same amount. Whose reasoning is correct?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Freya is right, it is land ice that raises the sea level
Why
Ibrahim is correct that both kinds are frozen water, and that melting either one adds liquid water somewhere. What he misses is that floating ice is already in the sea. A floating block pushes aside exactly its own weight of water — that is what floating means. When it melts, it turns into just that amount of water and fills the space it was already taking up, so the level does not change. Ice on land is different: it is water that is stored out of the ocean, stacked on rock. When it melts and flows into the sea, it is new water that was not there before. The Greenland ice sheet alone holds enough to raise the oceans by about seven metres, and Antarctica's holds far more. This is why scientists watching sea level pay most attention to land ice. Test: put ice cubes in a glass of water, mark the level and let them melt — the mark does not move. Now pile ice on a rack above a second glass and let it drip in — that level rises. Freya is right: melting land ice raises the sea level, while melting sea ice barely changes it.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in World Geography