World History
"World History" is full of ideas that feel obviously true until you look closer. Below are real disagreements about it — read each one and decide who you'd back.
Timur says the Silk Road was one long road from China to Europe, along which merchants carried silk from one end to the other. Mei says it was a web of many routes over land and sea; goods moved on from one trader to the next; and spices, paper, glass and new ideas travelled along with the silk. Whose description is more accurate?
Anika says the digits the whole world uses today — 0 to 9 — were developed in India and reached Europe through Arab mathematicians, which is why Europeans came to call them "Arabic numerals". Pierre says they must have been invented in Arabia — the name says so. Who is right?
Ben says that before Columbus sailed in 1492 everyone believed the Earth was flat, and that Columbus proved it was round. Nadia says educated people had known the Earth was a sphere since ancient Greece — a Greek scholar had even measured its circumference around 240 BCE. Who is right?
Camille says there is no reliable evidence that Marie Antoinette, the queen of France, ever said "Let them eat cake." The line was written down in a book, about "a great princess", when Marie Antoinette was a child of about nine who had not even come to France yet. Jack says everybody knows she said it, so it must be true. Whose reasoning holds up?
Hans says printing was invented by Johannes Gutenberg around 1450; before him nobody had ever printed anything. Jiwoo says printing existed in East Asia centuries earlier: a printed book from the year 868 still survives from China, and in Korea a book was printed with movable metal type in 1377. Whose claim stands up to the evidence?
Giulia says the saying "Nero fiddled while Rome burned" cannot be literally true: the great fire of Rome was in the year 64, and the fiddle, or violin, was not invented until about 1,500 years later. Sam says a saying that famous must be based on something that really happened. Whose reasoning is stronger?
Want to know who's right, and why? Reason it out yourself — free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Start thinking on Socho →