Giulia says the saying "Nero fiddled while Rome burned" cannot be literally true: the great fire…
Giulia says the saying "Nero fiddled while Rome burned" cannot be literally true: the great fire of Rome was in the year 64, and the fiddle, or violin, was not invented until about 1,500 years later. Sam says a saying that famous must be based on something that really happened. Whose reasoning is stronger?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Giulia is right, the violin did not exist yet
Why
Sam's rule — famous sayings come from real events — is often partly true, and here there really was a great fire, in the year 64, when Nero was emperor. But the details of a saying can be checked one by one, and this one fails a simple test. The fiddle belongs to the violin family, which first appeared in Italy in the 1500s, roughly fifteen centuries after the fire. Nero could not have played an instrument that did not exist. What is more, the Roman historian Tacitus, who was alive at the time, wrote that Nero was not even in Rome when the fire began but in the town of Antium, and that he returned to organise shelter and food for people. Later writers, who disliked Nero, told the story of him singing while the city burned, and much later the English phrase turned the singing into fiddling. Test: check every object in an old story against the date it was invented — an object out of its time shows the story was shaped later. Giulia is right: the saying cannot be literally true, because the violin was invented about 1,500 years after the fire.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in World History