Camille says there is no reliable evidence that Marie Antoinette, the queen of France, ever said…
Camille says there is no reliable evidence that Marie Antoinette, the queen of France, ever said "Let them eat cake." The line was written down in a book, about "a great princess", when Marie Antoinette was a child of about nine who had not even come to France yet. Jack says everybody knows she said it, so it must be true. Whose reasoning holds up?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Camille is right, the line was pinned on her afterwards
Why
Jack is relying on how often he has heard it — and it truly is one of the most repeated quotations in history. But repetition tells you how far a story has travelled, not whether it is true. The dates are what matter here. The line appears in the memoirs of the writer Jean-Jacques Rousseau, in a part written around 1765, where he says 'a great princess' once said it. Marie Antoinette was born in 1755, so she was about nine, living in Austria, and did not arrive in France until 1770. He cannot have meant her. No letter, diary or record from her own lifetime has her saying it; the words were attached to her name years later, when people were angry with the royal family. Test: for any famous quotation, ask where it was first written down, and when — if the date is wrong for the speaker, the quotation is not theirs. Camille is right: there is no evidence Marie Antoinette said it, and the line was already in print when she was a child.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in World History