Timur says the Silk Road was one long road from China to Europe, along which merchants carried…
Timur says the Silk Road was one long road from China to Europe, along which merchants carried silk from one end to the other. Mei says it was a web of many routes over land and sea; goods moved on from one trader to the next; and spices, paper, glass and new ideas travelled along with the silk. Whose description is more accurate?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Mei is right, it was a web of routes carrying much more than silk
Why
Timur is taking the name literally, which is a natural thing to do: 'Silk Road' sounds like one road, built for silk. But the name is modern. A German geographer coined it in 1877; the traders themselves never called it that. What really existed, for well over a thousand years, was a shifting network of caravan tracks across deserts and mountains, plus sea routes around the coasts of Asia. Hardly anyone travelled the whole distance. A bale of silk would be sold on from trader to trader, city to city, changing hands many times before it reached the Mediterranean. Silk was only one of the goods: spices, glass, horses, cotton and paper moved too, and so did things that weigh nothing — the knowledge of how to make paper, new crops, new numbers, stories and music. Test: follow papermaking on a map — it began in China and reached Europe about a thousand years later, passing from region to region along these routes. Mei is right: the Silk Road was a network of many routes that carried goods and ideas, not a single road for silk.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in World History