Ben says that before Columbus sailed in 1492 everyone believed the Earth was flat, and that…
Ben says that before Columbus sailed in 1492 everyone believed the Earth was flat, and that Columbus proved it was round. Nadia says educated people had known the Earth was a sphere since ancient Greece — a Greek scholar had even measured its circumference around 240 BCE. Who is right?
Who do you think is right? Pick one.
The answer: Nadia is right, people knew the Earth was round long before
Why
Ben's version is in many old storybooks, which is why it feels like a fact. But scholars in Europe, the Arab world and India had accepted a round Earth for many centuries before 1492. Around 240 BCE the Greek scholar Eratosthenes even measured it: he compared the lengths of shadows at noon in two Egyptian cities a known distance apart, and worked out a circumference close to the real 40,000 km. Sailors also saw the evidence for themselves — a ship sailing away disappears hull first and mast last, as if going over a curve. The real argument about Columbus was about size. He thought the Earth was much smaller, and Asia much closer, than it is. His critics said the distance was far too great for his ships, and they were correct about that; he only survived because an unknown continent lay in between. Test: watch a ship leave harbour through binoculars — the bottom vanishes first. Nadia is right: a round Earth had been known since ancient Greece, long before Columbus.
On Socho, you explain your thinking out loud and a coach asks about YOUR reasoning — one question a day, free, in Hindi, Hinglish or English.
Try a question on Socho →More disagreements in World History